The Saintly Paradox of King Louis – Mike Carsten OFS's Speechify Podcasts
A Franciscan Reflection
There is a profound, almost jarring tension at the heart of the Secular Franciscan vocation—one that becomes increasingly apparent after decades of striving to live the Rule. We look to St. Francis of Assisi, who walked away from every ounce of earthly power and privilege to embrace the pure, prophetic ideal of absolute minority. Yet, alongside him, the Church offers us King Louis IX as our co-patron. Louis wore a crown, governed a vast nation, and tragically led armies into crusades that resulted in devastating loss of life.
This juxtaposition is not a historical accident; it is a necessary mirror for those of us called to the secular state. The prophetic ideal of Assisi was born outside temporal structures, but our vocation is forged squarely within them. The true testing ground for our Rule is not a remote hermitage, but the beautiful, demanding realities of marriage, the generations of children and grandchildren gathered around the table, and the quiet responsibilities of local civic life. We cannot simply retreat from the world. We must incarnate the Gospel in its messy, practical realities.
The following reflection explores this Franciscan paradox. Rooted in Catholic moral theology and the essential documents of the OFS, it examines the dangers of the “moral offset” in modern leadership and the uncompromising demands of our vocation. We are challenged to bridge the gap between the prophet and the statesman, demanding a seamless Gospel in a fractured world—remembering always that we are called not to conquer the culture, but to wash its feet.
The Crown and the Hair Shirt: The Life of King Louis IX
To understand the paradox of St. Louis, one must first understand the man beneath the royal regalia. Born in 1214, Louis inherited the French throne at just twelve. His early reign was fiercely protected by his mother, Blanche of Castile, who instilled in him a moral absolute that would define his entire life: “I would rather see you fall dead at my feet,” she told him, “than ever commit a single mortal sin.”
Louis took this to heart. As he grew into his kingship, he became a living contradiction to the despotic monarchs of his era. He possessed the greatest treasury and military in Europe, yet he wore a coarse hair shirt beneath his fine robes. He built the magnificent Sainte-Chapelle in Paris to house the Crown of Thorns, but he also quietly slipped out of his palace to wash the sores of lepers. He personally fed over a hundred destitute citizens from his own table every day.
For Louis, royal power was not a privilege; it was a heavy burden of Christian stewardship. He revolutionized French law by abolishing trial by combat, instituting the presumption of innocence, and forbidding his officials from taking bribes. He famously held an open court under an oak tree in the forest of Vincennes, allowing the poorest serfs to bypass the corrupt nobility and appeal directly to their king for justice.
The Crusader King
Yet, this same man was entirely captive to the tragic theology of his era. In 1244, while suffering from a near-fatal illness, Louis made a vow to take up the cross and liberate the Holy Land. To the 13th-century mind, a crusade was viewed as the ultimate act of caritas (charity) and defensive penance.
In 1248, he launched the Seventh Crusade, mobilizing a massive armada and invading Egypt. After an initial victory at Damietta, the campaign turned into a catastrophic failure. His army was outmaneuvered, starved, and decimated by disease at Mansourah and Fariskur. Thousands of his men were killed or captured, and Louis himself was taken prisoner. Ransomed at an exorbitant price, he did not return home in defeat. Instead, he spent four years in the Levant, humbly rebuilding the defenses of Christian cities like Acre and Jaffa.
Years later, his zeal remained unquenched. In 1270, an aging, frail Louis launched the Eighth Crusade, landing in Tunis under the misguided hope that the local emir might convert to Christianity. Almost immediately upon landing, a fierce epidemic of typhus and dysentery swept through the crusader camp. Thousands died. On August 25, 1270, King Louis IX succumbed to the disease, dying as a penitent on a bed of ashes scattered on the floor of his tent, whispering the words of the Psalmist: “Lord, I will enter into your house…”
Dismantling the “Moral Offset” Trap
Holding these two figures—the unarmed Francis and the Crusader King—together requires confronting a dangerous trap: the idea of a “moral offset.” It can be tempting to look at Louis’s personal charity and use it to excuse his crusades, but doing so risks providing theological cover for the hypocrisy of modern politicians and Church leaders.
Catholic moral theology is absolute: the ends never justify the means, and a good act does not permit or excuse an evil one.
- No Cover for Modern Hypocrisy: Modern leaders—both secular and religious—often point to their championing of a specific righteous cause (e.g., passing a specific law, funding a charity, or defending a traditional value) to demand a “free pass” for their corruption, aggression, or neglect of the marginalized. St. Louis must never be weaponized to justify this.
- The Context of Era vs. Modern Accountability: When evaluating Louis, one must acknowledge that he was trapped by the limitations of a 13th-century theology that falsely equated warfare with charity. Modern leaders, however, benefit from centuries of clarified Catholic Social Teaching. They do not have the excuse of medieval ignorance; they are fully accountable for the harm they cause today.
- Canonizing the Penitent, Not the Policy: The Church canonizes a saint for their interior penitence, their radical prayer life, and their willingness to subject their ego to Christ—not their geopolitical decisions or military strategies. Acknowledging that Louis fed the poor does not make the deaths of tens of thousands in his crusades acceptable. It simply reveals that human beings—even saints—are profoundly fractured.
A Vocation Lived in the World
The Secular Franciscan path is not lived in a hermitage; it is often forged in the family and the local community. The true testing ground for the Rule is within the walls of the home and the daily interactions of ordinary civic life.
Secular Franciscans are called to possess Francis’s radical reliance on God and perfect joy, but must apply it with Louis’s profound sense of stewardship over the souls, resources, and systems entrusted to their care. This means demanding a seamless Gospel. A Secular Franciscan cannot accept compartmentalized leadership or give a pass to leaders who claim to be “pro-life” but ignore the poor, or “pro-peace” but ignore the unborn.
Washing Feet, Not Wielding Swords
The OFS’s essential documents are uncompromising in their call. Article 19 demands that Secular Franciscans be messengers of peace, seeking unity through dialogue. Looking at Louis’s historical failures alongside his intimate charity challenges the modern believer to strip away any remaining combativeness in their own hearts.
St. Francis did not flatter the rich or excuse the violent. The modern Franciscan is called to hold temporal and spiritual leaders accountable to the entire Gospel, stripping away the “cover” of their selective good deeds. The Franciscan is not called to conquer the culture; they are called to wash its feet.
Resources for Further Study
1. The Franciscan Paradox: Prophet vs. Statesman
- St. Louis IX as Co-Patron of the OFS: Read a historical overview of King Louis IX, why he was seen as a “quintessential Christian ruler,” and his significance as the patron of the Secular Franciscan Order.
2. The Messy Reality of Secular Responsibility & The Duty of Justice
- OFS Rule, Article 15 (Systemic Justice): The Rule calls Secular Franciscans to promote justice through the testimony of their lives and courageous initiatives.
- The Spiritual Testament of St. Louis: A direct look at how Louis advised his son to rule with justice, lean toward the poor man over the rich man, and govern with compassion—actions born from his secular vocation.
3. The Vocation Lived in the Home
- Embracing the Gospel in Ordinary Life: Read how Secular Franciscans, following the model of St. Louis, are called to live their vocation actively within marriage, parenthood, and civic life rather than retreating from the world.
4. Washing Feet, Not Wielding Swords (Peacemaking)
- OFS Rule, Article 19 (Dialogue and Peacemaking): Read the current guidelines and Rule structures for the Secular Franciscan Order, emphasizing the call to be messengers of joy and hope, seeking unity through dialogue.
Discover more from Chasing The Wild Goose
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
